Corrections or additions?

This article by Richard K. Rein was prepared for the November 27, 2002 edition of U.S. 1 Newspaper. All rights reserved.

The McPhee Sisters

How do you figure those remarkable McPhee sisters?

Martha McPhee was nominated this year for a National Book Award for

her novel "Gorgeous Lies," published by Harcourt and a sequel

to "Bright Angel Time" (Random House). Jenny McPhee’s first

novel, "The Center of Things," has just come out in paperback

(Ballantine). Another sister, Laura, is a photographer who collaborated

with Jenny and Martha on "Girls: Ordinary Girls and Their Extraordinary

Pursuits," also published by Random House.

It’s a literary clan, and two of them, Jenny and Martha, along with

their half-sister Joan Sullivan, author of "An American Voter:

My Love Affair with Presidential Politics," a memoir of her involvement

in Bill Bradley’s 2000 Presidential primary campaign, are showing

up at the Princeton University Store on Wednesday, December 4, to

talk about their lives and their work. It’s a literary town, Princeton,

with a lot of writers and would-be writers walking the sidewalks.

But this is the only family I can think of that has sent a troika

of writers onto center stage at one time. It’s the Brontes — Charlotte

and Emily — plus one.

You might want to attribute it all to their father, author John McPhee,

who has written dozens of books of literary non-fiction on subjects

as diverse as basketball, oranges, geology, and the Pine Barrens.

McPhee also served for many years as a teacher of expository writing

at Princeton University and as a mentor to writers famous and obscure.

Many years ago, when I was starting out as a freelance writer, I made

the pilgrimage to McPhee’s office, then located on Nassau Street,

just above Tulane Alley and the entrance to the Annex. What advice

could he give an obscure guy like me, I wanted to know. I still remember

his answer: Try your hand at every conceivable writing form. Someone

who struggles forever to write a 3,000-word magazine piece might in

fact be a potential Pulitzer Prize winner at the 300-word newspaper

editorial — but you would never know unless you gave each form

a try.

Just a few weeks ago, I was editing a U.S. 1 story about Tim Lefens,

an artist who created a program that developed the creative talents

of people with disabilities. When Lefens set out to write a book about

his efforts, he sought the guidance of John McPhee. The advice, as

recalled by the artist: "Tim, number one, you’re not a writer,

but you can tell one hell of a story, so just write the book the way

you talk." If this is what virtual strangers glean from John McPhee,

imagine the amount of artistic vision that his daughters might have


But that doesn’t fully explain the literary light of the McPhee girls’

half sister, Joan Sullivan, that author of the memoir of the Bill

Bradley campaign. Sullivan is also an accomplished teacher, friends

of the family say, who has taken her students at a public high school

in the South Bronx and transformed them into some of New York City’s

best and brightest young people.

How do you explain these McPhee and Sullivan girls (the other McPhee

sister, Sarah, is an architectural historian). Maybe it’s their mother,

Pryde Brown, who 30 years ago joined a handful of other women in Princeton

to study the relative portrayals of boys and girls in school textbooks.

As documented in their 1972 book, "Dick and Jane as Victims,"

boys in these books were three times more likely than girls to be

involved in a creative or clever activity.

More recently Pryde Brown has become known as the pre-eminent portrait

photographer in town. So maybe some of John has rubbed off on these

young women, and maybe some of Pryde.

And maybe it’s also some of another adult who loomed large in the

lives of all these kids as they were growing up. That would be Pryde’s

second husband, Dan Sullivan, who had four kids when he met Pryde

— Joan is their mutual creation, the ninth child in this family

that blended together in the early 1970s.

Dan Sullivan, who died four or five years ago, is a man I wrote about

years ago — he was a legal milestone, the first man in New Jersey

to ever receive alimony from his ex-wife. That was an oddity that

attracted the attention of People magazine in the mid 1970s, and I

was the reporter.

Over the years I encountered Sullivan a few times socially, but my

superficial impression was that all those alimony dollars were just

yellow bricks on the road to failure. The only money he actually earned,

people would say, was from playing poker.

Now I feel as if I know Dan Sullivan better — and he’s a lot more

than a freeloader who earned spare change playing cards. My insight

is from those two books by Martha McPhee, which I read in succession

in recent weeks. The novels are fiction, of course, not biographies

of anyone in particular. But Martha’s work, I have been told by friends,

is another piece of fiction that mines the break-up of the McPhee

marriage. The first was "Shoot the Moon," the 1981 movie based

on a screenplay by a 1953 Princeton classmate of McPhee.

Martha’s novels not only allude to the marriage’s demise, but also

to Pryde’s subsequent free-form marital life with Dan Sullivan. The

novels are brimming with telling details that have some people in

town trying to sort out the fact from the fiction: Who is that architect

with the French name, that lawyer who is also a private pilot, and

the duck lady — who is that duck lady? From "Bright Angel


Our father had left the summer before, on the day the men

landed on the moon. He had made a promise with us that morning: He

would bring the TV out to the yard on the end of a long extension

cord so that we could stare up at the moon while watching the men

walk on it. He was going to tell us about the geology of the moon,

but instead he walked away with the wife of his childhood friend to

make a life of his own.

From "Gorgeous Lies:"

It was the mid 1970s and this interest in blended families

was a trend that had begun with the divorce boom, and then the "Brady

Bunch, and now everyone, everywhere wanted to know how it was really

working out . . .

They were famous for many reasons. They were famous because

they lived on a vast piece of property that was supposed to be a farm

but was not a farm at all . . . They were famous because Anton [Dan]

was a Gestalt therapist and in town he had a reputation for holding

therapy sessions on his front lawn . . . They were famous because

Anton did not have a traditional job and Eve [Pryde] did, and it was

Eve who brought home the money. "Anton is a good feminist and

a wonderful mother," Eve would say.

That’s what brought me — a struggling young freelance writer

for People magazine — out to the Sullivan-McPhee homestead a few

miles north of Princeton in the mid 1970s. Here’s how it plays out

in "Gorgeous Lies:"

There was Anton big as day on the cover of People Magazine

(actually it was Marlon Brando, but it looked so much like Anton that

even the kids, even Eve, at first thought Brandon was Anton). Inside

that issue was a five-page spread on the family with pictures, covered

by a famous reporter. Anton, for real, on page sixty-five with his

bright, electrifying smile, a dustpan and brush in hand sweeping up

the kitchen floor . . . All of the kids laughed when they saw that

picture; they’d never seen Anton before with a dustpan in his hand.

A little lie apparently conveyed by me and People magazine —

part of a bundle of gorgeous lies told and lived by the characters

in the novel.

Of the two novels I found "Gorgeous Lies" much more compelling.

"Bright Angel Time" was centered on the process of the two

families coming together — life is the journey, not the destination,

the novel instructed. But while that may be a wonderful way to live,

I’m not sure it’s a great structure for a novel.

"Gorgeous Lies," in contrast, follows a path toward an inevitable

destination — the death of Anton. One of the gorgeous lies may

be Anton’s insistence that he is an extraordinary philosopher, at

work on a revolutionary treatise:

Sometimes Anton would drive. Mozart or Beethoven or

Chopin or Bach or anyone classical on the radio. His car gliding over

the roads. . . Somewhere. Anywhere. It gave him time to think. . .

I just need a little time, he would say to himself — a bargain.

Just a little more time and I’ll get it finished. That "it,"

that little "it" was his book. . .

Rolling down the window, he practiced his title on the

air. "To Deny Our Hearts: Contemporary Attacks on Sexual Passion."

He was a philosopher. He had his doctorat d’etat from the Sorbonne.

He had worked beside R. D. Laing — taken acid with the man —

and studied with Paul Ricoeur and Norman Brown. He had published plenty

of articles. All he needed now was a book.

But of course that book never is written. At the end the man

who has given his kids and her kids and their kid hope and optimism

in the face of one debacle after another turns to the kids as he faces

his own fears:

He cried because he had no purpose. He cried because he

was a philosopher pregnant with ideas that he could not birth. . .

At his death he would have produced fifty-four outlines

and no book. Thousands of index cards with scrawled notes and no book.

Thousands of index cards with quotations from famous men who had produced

books. Ten collages and no book. His mind would be an archive of knowledge

but no book.

So now three of the sisters are showing up together at the Princeton

University Store, to talk about their books and how they came to be

writers. The drive may well spring from all the literary accomplishments

of John McPhee and the artistic endeavors of Pryde Brown. But maybe

it’s also inspired by the dreams — unrealized dreams — of

the other man in their lives. Go figure.

Previous Story

Corrections or additions?

This page is published by

— the web site for U.S. 1 Newspaper in Princeton, New Jersey.

Facebook Comments