Corrections or additions?
This review by Simon Saltzman was prepared for the May 26, 2004
issue of U.S. 1 Newspaper. All rights reserved.
NY Review: ‘Caroline, or Change’
There is a lot of anger vented through music in "Caroline, or Change," the nearly sung-through musical by Tony Award-winner Tony Kushner (book and lyrics) and Jeanine Tesori (music). Operatic in its aspirations and dramatic in its presentation, this unusual musical made enough friends and supporters during its successful run earlier this season Off-Broadway to justify a move to Broadway. I hope they are right. The production fits as snugly into the Eugene O’Neill Theater as it did at the Public Theater. A second visit confirms its major pleasures more than its minor flaws. If anything, the performances are all a bit sharper. The score also sounds richer.
The story, filled with racial and social obstructions, is serious to the point of sadness and, rather than warming your heart, it grabs and twists it into a Gordian knot. With that said, I also think it is filled with greatness. The musical’s most original device is the use of a washing machine, clothes dryer, a radio, an old bus, and even a moon that sing. These anthropomorphic characters (a bow, undoubtedly, to illustrator Maurice Sendak with whom Kushner collaborated with on a children’s book "Brundibar" and on "The Art of Maurice Sendak"), fit cleverly into the musical’s fierce and fanciful reality.
At times they are used to enhance and brighten a world that is suddenly filled with unsettling and even tragic events. They also serve to rev up the musical’s autobiographical and political engine, driven in equal parts by Noah Gellman (Harrison Chad) a Jewish boy growing up in Lake Charles, Louisiana during the early 1960s, and the title character Caroline (Tonya Pinkens), his family’s black maid.
Pinkens is brilliant and unforgettable as the opinionated day-worker caught between her own personal bitterness and the increasing intensity of the racial turmoil around her. Caroline is also caught between the changes she sees in her closest friend, her children, and the family for whom she works.
Under George C. Wolf’s sensitive direction, Kushner’s artfully compacted two-and-a-half hour tome (that is comparing it to the seven hours of "Angels in America" and the four hours of "Homebody/Kabul") emerges not only as a thoughtful and unsettling examination of the increasingly volatile relationship between the boy, Noah, and the maid, but also of the endangered feelings and views of their families, whose lives are worlds apart.
Above all is the change that threatens the uneasy bond between Carolyn and Noah and has existed ever since Noah’s father, Stuart (David Costabile), remarried following his wife’s death from cancer. Unknown to his nervous-to-a-fault stepmother, Rose (Veanne Cox), who tries, but does not seem to know how to reach the boy, is that Noah’s most guilty secret pleasure is getting to light Caroline’s cigarete as she attends to the laundry in the basement.
Noah’s habit of leaving change in his pockets leads Rose to punish him by letting Caroline keep it. Although the change, mostly quarters, means a lot to Caroline, who is feeding her three children on her salary of $30 a week, it creates a rift between her and Noah, further aggravated by her finding a misplaced $20 bill.
The quality of the acting and the singing by a large company is notable. The sheer force of Pinkens’ intensity as a 39-year-old divorcee with a son fighting in Vietnam, propels her outstanding performance both vocally and dramatically.
A terrific impression of impetuous youth is created by the young and very talented young Chad, as Noah. Cox finds a realistic mix of humor and poignancy to drive Rose’s anxieties, with Costabile offering sturdy support as her husband, a musician living in his own world. Both Chandra Wilson, as Caroline’s friend Dotty and Anika Noni Rose, as Caroline’s daughter Emmie make solid impressions with their progressive commitment to change. Larry Keith puts a lot of punch into his role as Mr. Stopnik, Rose’s visiting Yankee father. His confrontation with Emmie during the family’s Chanukah celebration serves to widen the gulf between the Gellmans, including Grandma and Grandpa Gellman (Alice Playton and Reathel Bean), and the Thidobeaux, including sons Jackie (Leon G. Thomas III) and Joe (Marcus Carl Franklin).
Although the Gellman family is shown as sympathetic, for obvious reasons, with the social equality and changes that African-Americans are seeking, they are also fearful of change, which is not surprising following the assassination of the President Kennedy. If the most visionary symbol is the moon (rapturously sung by the gauze-enveloped Adriane Lenox), the more whimsically-coded radio takes the form of a Supremes-like group in the persons of Tracy Nicole Chapman, Marva Hicks, and Ramona Keller. Capathia Jenkins and Chuck Cooper give a bright human resonance to their comic roles as washer and dryer, respectively. Cooper’s bass voice is heard again as the rickety old bus for black people.
The bright mobile settings by Ricardo Hernandez expand and contract to create both expansive and intimate spaces as the play, enhanced by Jules Fisher and Peggy Eisenhauer’s lighting, moves fluidly from the basement to the living room to the out-of-doors and even into dreams. Paul Tazwell costumes have the opportunity to be true to the period as well as take their flights of fancy.
Although the program does not include a song list, Tesori’s expansive score is melodic, vibrant, and eclectic, ranging from neo-operatic to R & B to Klezmer. It far outshines her contributions for "Thoroughly Modern Millie." The orchestrations (the work of Rick Bassett, Joseph Joubert, and Buryl Red) and the musical direction of Linda Twine enable every word of the libretto to come through clearly. As a bold new musical, "Caroline, or Change" doesn’t offer its characters solutions, but only the lesson to accept change when it comes and run with it with no regrets.
– Simon Saltzman
Caroline, or Change, Eugene O’Neill Theater, 230 West 49th Street. For tickets call 212-239-6200
Corrections or additions?
This page is published by PrincetonInfo.com
— the web site for U.S. 1 Newspaper in Princeton, New Jersey.