Corrections or additions?

This article by LucyAnn Dunlap was prepared for the April 19, 2006

issue of U.S. 1 Newspaper. All rights reserved.

Mastrosimone on Home Turf

Playwright William Mastrosimone’s father, who was born in 1915 to

immigrant parents, saw his "American Dream" demolished when everything

he had worked for and built was taken from him in 1969 by right of

"eminent domain." This event and the story of the family dealing with

this blow inspired Mastrosimone to write the play "A Stone Carver,"

whose production marks the conclusion of the Passage Theater’s 20th

anniversary season. On Monday, April 24, Mastrosimone and director

Robert Kalkin hold a discussion about the play at Princeton Public


Mastrosimone’s father was a self-made man who built "with his own

hands" a building complex on a large parcel of land on the outskirts

of Trenton. There was an apartment building and an office building.

Later he would add an ice-cream parlor and a bowling alley. "We lived

above the office building," says Mastrosimone in a phone interview

from his home in Pennsylvania where he lives with his wife and

children. "That was our family life; we lived in the middle of his

little empire." The family included parents and five children: Bill,

three older brothers, and a younger sister. Mastrosimone’s own

children include two older stepsons – one away at college, the other

attending college locally. Then there are his two daughters and an

orphan girl from Afghanistan.

It was mystifying to the senior Mastrosimone when, one day in 1969, a

yellow car from the state drove up to tell him that his property was

condemned. Supposedly, the state had decided to put Route I-95 through

his land. Not wanting to sell was not an option. Back then, not too

many people had heard of "eminent domain." The final irony is that the

highway did not come this way. The buildings became a warehouse for

trucks, was finally demolished, and now Mastrosimone is pretty sure

there is a McDonalds there.

He remembers sitting around the kitchen table unable to fathom the

meaning of this. "What I saw was very traumatic for me and more so for

my father. What was traumatic about it was that I saw my father

emasculated." Thinking of this later, Mastrosimone came to the

conclusion that "the American Dream" is really phony. "The American

Dream is that if you work hard, you can make a great life for

yourself. What you have is yours. But it’s not true. With eminent

domain they can take anything."

The experience destroyed Mastrosimone’s father, who though he was able

to continue with new business, never recovered emotionally.

Mastrosimone remembers that his father was still just as angry and

talked about it just as passionately right before he died as he did

when it happened. "It is a wound that never healed," says

Mastrosimone. Describing his father as very patriotic, Mastrosimone

feels that this very love of country made it difficult for his father

to talk about what had happened. "He knew that if we would talk about

this too much it would lead us to the conclusion that there’s really

something wrong in America. There seemed to be the vestiges of

kingship that his family thought were left behind."

`A Stone Carver" began more than 30 years ago when Mastrosimone was a

student. After dropping out of Tulane University in 1969 after one

year of pre-med studies ("It was too far and I didn’t have the

money.") he decided to educate himself, preparing to become a writer.

He wrote a novel and a play, which he didn’t finish. In 1973, he went

to Rider College before it became a university, where he met people

who encouraged his writing. He began thinking about a play dealing

with, he says, the "emotional event and trauma of what had happened to

my family." The following year, he was accepted into the first class

of the Mason Gross School of the Arts. The first week there, his

graduate playwriting teacher, who would become his mentor, Betty

Comtois, assigned a playwriting project due by the end of the year. "I

was so inspired that I sat down and wrote the play in two weeks," says


Over the years "A Stone Carver" has been produced, but after a short

Off-Broadway run (using the title "The Understanding") – which was a

big disappointment to the playwright – he and his agent have been very

stingy with the rights to this play. He has withheld any further New

York City productions since 1980. "I didn’t want to have a bad

production of this." It is such a special play for him, so close to

his heart. It played at Seattle Rep in 1987 and was a produced in

Chicago a few years ago. On his desk in his office, Mastrosimone has a

copy of the script in Russian thanks to a production in Moscow before

the fall of the USSR. "It ran there for a long time," the playwright

says. Surprised by only just now thinking of the relevance of this, he

says, "The power of the state that could do anything must have made

this play have special meaning to them."

Like any good writer, Mastrosimone has used his family’s personal

drama as a starting point, but the resulting play is his invention.

In fact, he describes the character of the father in the play – who

will be portrayed by actor Dan Lauria, familiar to George Street

Playhouse audiences in his recent appearances in "Inspecting Carol"

and "The Pillowman" – as a composite of his father and his uncle. The

stone carver, Agostino Malatesta, is the last holdout before the

developer’s bulldozer. He is standing guard over the house he built of

limestone and is surrounded by stone angels that he has carved in the

image of his dead wife. His own son and his fiancee have come to

"reason" with him that he must step aside for "progress." This family

conflict between the two generations proves the central conflict of

the play. "This is a family story," says Mastrosimone. Earlier drafts

of this play were much more political, focusing on the power of the

state versus the rights of the individual. He says: "The politics have

been pushed way in the background but are still there."

He finds it telling that when lawyers, government officials, or public

relations people looked for a name for confiscating private property

for what they term "the public good," they had to go back to the

middle ages for a term – eminent domain. "That was when kings had the

right to take anything they wanted," says Mastrosimone.

Obviously heartfelt, he adds, "Nowadays it’s worse. Before it was

about `We want to build a hospital; we want to do something for the

public good.’ Now they still call it the public good, but now they

want to build condos. They want to increase the tax base. They’re in

cahoots with developers. Seize a prime piece of land from people who

are just living there."

A website sponsored by an advocacy group tracks cases of eminent

domain nationwide. Among New Jersey listings is the home of a World

War II veteran who is dying of lung cancer. This land is "needed" for

a luxury condo. The link to explore this nationwide problem is

Mastrosimone’s family is very important to him and so is his home in

Pennsylvania. "A home is a sacred place. Now in the United States

nothing is sacred unless it’s a church, synagogue, or mosque. But a

home is a sacred place to me because people are born there, die there,

and everything in between. The walls themselves trigger memories. Your

memories are treasures. I think that homes should be sacred."

A man of words, but also a man of great heart, he follows up with

action and generosity. These are qualities he has passed on to his

family. "My daughters know that there are a lot of people in the world

who are not as fortunate as us. My parents taught me you’ve got to

give something back. I saw my parents do that all the time. They did

it on a local level. I have an opportunity to do it in the orphanages

in Afghanistan. On a bigger scale." It was his daughters’ idea to

bring an Afghan girl into our family.

In the fall of 2003, his play, "The Afghan Women," premiered at

Passage Theater. Since then all profits from this play have helped to

support two orphanages and two clinics in Afghanistan. The play is

optioned for a Broadway production next season. If it is successful,

Mastrosimone plans to use those profits to expand the work in

Afghanistan, building a new facility. He says that too many men there

are out of work, their only asset a gun-for-hire to various warlords.

"These are guys who want to get married, live traditional lives, but

there’s nothing else for them." The idea for the new project is "Give

us your gun and we’ll give you a profession." Mastrosimone explains

that teaching working skills is already a part of the education in the

orphanages, but with the new building, they plan to expand to young

people in their 20s and 30s.

Another play that Mastrosimone has written is "Bang, Bang, You’re

Dead." Dealing with violence in American schools, the rights to this

play are free on the Internet so that high schools have access to it.

The television version of this play won an Emmy and a Peabody Award.

How can Mastrosimone afford to be so generous? He makes a lot of money

writing for television and movies. Since his first major theatrical

success with "Extremities" in 1982 — a play that would later be made

into a movie starring Farrah Fawcett, he has been offered a number of

writing assignments for television movies. He won a Golden Globe Award

for the mini-series "Sinatra" (1992). Along with Steven Spielberg,

Dreamworks, and TNT, he was head writer, co-producer, and creator of

the televsion series "Into The West," which won the Critics Choice

Award for Best Picture Made for Television in 2005, and the Wrangler

Award from the National Cowboy & Western Museum for "Outstanding

Television Feature of 2005." He describes this experience as basically

doing six movies at the same time. "It was very hard." And he took a

year off when that project was completed to recoup his energies.

`I have some dreams that I’ve had before, aspirations that I’ve

neglected. One of them is a story about my childhood." His current

list of projects is mind-boggling. He’s almost through with a novel

called "The Blackberry Wars." And he’s also working on a musical based

on a play he wrote while at Mason Gross. It was called "Ham" – Hamlet

done as a western. Recently he found a composer who is interested in

working on this, writing a country western score, of course. "I

actually have a number of plays lined up, some researched, half

written, or more than that in some."

For now, he would like to invite people who’ve lost their homes to

eminent domain to come to see "A Stone Carver." "We’ll see what

happens. Maybe it will call some attention to the practice. This may

develop into something."

— LucyAnn Dunlap

"A Stone Carver," Monday, April 24, 7:30 p.m., Princeton Public

Library, Community Room, first floor, 65 Witherspoon Street,

Award-winning playwright and Trenton native William Mastrosimone and

acclaimed director Robert Kalfin in a discussion of their

collaboration on "A Stone Carver." Set in Trenton, the play examines

the generational conflicts of a proud Sicilian-American father (played

by Dan Lauria), and his son, as they are played out in an eminent

domain battle over the home the father built. 609-924-8822.

Next Story

Corrections or additions?

This page is published by

— the web site for U.S. 1 Newspaper in Princeton, New Jersey.

Facebook Comments